Monday, November 16, 2026

Middletown out of Sec. IX Championship: Newburgh to play VC tomorrow

Middletown. Football team withdraws court petition to play after disqualification.


By Felicia Hodges

The Middie Bears history-making football season is over.

The team, which was undefeated for the first time since 1965, didn’t lose at all on the gridiron this season – but they were ousted from the Section IX Class AA Championships for a rule violation involving a player who was not eligible to compete in the post-season contest.

According to the New York State Public High School Athletic Association (NYSPHAA) Handbook, football players are required to have at least been on the roster for a minimum of three regular-season games. Athletes with fewer than three are ineligible, and playing an ineligible athlete results in a forfeit.

After defeating Valley Central 48-15 in last week’s semi-final, Middletown was slated to head to the finals to face number 2 seed Newburgh Free Academy this Saturday at Monroe-Woodbury High School. But a discovery that a Middletown special teams player entered the game after having played in only two regular season games resulted in Valley Central being named the other championship finalist.

Published reports indicate that the Enlarged City School District of Middletown acknowledged the eligibility violation but appealed to Section IX and NYSPHAA to have the forfeiture overturned, arguing in part that the ineligible player’s contribution in the Valley Central game had little effect on the game’s outcome.

On Wednesday, school district Superintendent Amy Creeden filed an Article 78 emergency petition in Orange County Supreme Court in a final attempt to have the ineligibility ruling overturned. The petition, however, was withdrawn by the district on Friday afternoon.

In September 2019, Middletown’s football team forfeited four games after a 19-year-old senior played in a game he was not eligible to participate in.

According to a statement filed with the Orange County Clerk on Friday morning by Valley Central Athletic Director Theresa Uhelsky, Middletown acknowledged then that its district would “create additional checks and balances in vetting the eligibility standards for all our athletes going forward.” The statement added that Middletown should have known about eligibility requirements and “should be responsible for any consequence if they were not informed of such a rule.”

Newburgh last played Valley Central on Oct. 30, with the Goldbacks beating the VC Vikings 27-0.

Valley Central will face Newburgh again tomorrow for the championship game. Kickoff is scheduled for 12 p.m.

 

Originally appeared in The Photo News on Nov. 13, 2026 (https://www.thephoto-news.com/news/local-news/middletown-out-of-sec-ix-championship-newburgh-to-play-vc-tomorrow-NK6387285).

No comments:

Post a Comment